Menu
 
Home | News | YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS!
 
News | 3rd September 2020
 

YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS!

Artists impression of how proposed flood defences may look

 
 
 

THE River Esk in Langholm will become a concrete drainage channel if a Scottish government-funded flood defence scheme is endorsed by the local authority.

It’s claimed that the river, along with the Wauchope, will be disconnected from the community by walls and embankments ranging from 1.3m to 2.2m high.

The 1 in 200 year flood defences will run from Mary Street downstream to the sewage works along the Esk and along Caroline Street on the Wauchope.

All trees and bushes on the riverbanks will be removed but the council is pledging to plant saplings.

The council flood team’s preferred option also proposes to dig a wide, shallow channel through Buccleuch Park to carry flood water from the Wauchope into the Esk during flood events.

The scheme was commissioned by the council and designed by consultants RPS who held two, three-day public consultation events in the town, the second one in February.

After this event, a group was set up to challenge the preferred option after a number of people expressed their disquiet at the scale of the scheme.

They believe it is financially driven because the government will pay 80 per cent of the £8m project, while the council pays 20 per cent.

The group believes that Langholm needs a flood scheme to protect waterside properties but says this design is over-engineered and will damage people’s quality of life by cutting them off from the rivers.

The group has set up a display in Welcome to Langholm’s window with photos showing the heights of the walls from eye level.

One of their complaints is that the council has provided only “bird’s eye views” on its video visuals which do not give a realistic picture of how they look to people on the ground.

Looking south from Langholm Bridge to Suspension Bridge
Looking south from Langholm Bridge to Suspension Bridge

Questions have been raised over where the ground level is and a council spokesperson said: “It is the height from the existing ground level on the land side, at the point where the defence is sited.”

Erika Luukas, who leads the group, is worried that there will be no more public engagement before the communities committee meets to recommend approval of the scheme.

If this goes ahead, there will be 28 days for the public to comment before the council approves the scheme.

She said: “We want a full design review. Langholm may need some flood defences but we deserve a better design.

“There is no funding (from the government) other than for a 1 in 200-year scheme so the council tried to get the money and then designed a scheme to fit that.

“The Esk will become a drainage channel, not a river. There will be no riverbank or trees. The river will no longer exist.

“The council’s report places no value on the impact from the loss of the trees but says the flood walls will improve people’s lives.

“People have been told that a 1 in 200-year flood is coming and have been terrified by that thought.

“I don’t deny it could happen but it is a minuscule risk.”

The group is concerned that the decision made on which option to recommend was done behind closed doors with stakeholders such as the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, the Environment Agency, Scottish Water and Scottish Natural Heritage.

It also thinks the council is wrong to say that only people living on the waterside are affected when everyone who enjoys the amenity of the river will be.
Erika has corresponded for several months with Michael Smith, the flood team leader, who has explained the flood order process.

Mr Smith told her: “Our proposed scheme provides a 1 in 200-year flood event protection and is an economically-viable solution.

“We have investigated all other options and these either do not give the necessary protection or economic viability. This is evidenced by all the information and reports on the website.”

He asks her to provide details of what the group considers to be a better solution or alternative scheme and evidence to support this.

He adds: “The scheme has gone through a transparent and comprehensive process over two years, involving extensive consideration of all possible options, consultation with stakeholders and two main public engagement events.

“In our next update report to the committee we will detail the work to date, current position and the programme and timescale which will include another public display event before publishing the scheme.

Erika said: “This puts the advocates of the current preferred option at a very significant advantage within this process.

“Our request for a pause and design review was flatly refused in March, despite being made very shortly after the drop-in event once many in our community had had an opportunity to fully digest the enormity of the proposals presented to us and despite more than 100 people immediately expressing major concerns.

“It’s frustrating to learn the staged schedule evades any of these concerns being raised in any timely or useful manner which may influence the ongoing design process or its currently ‘unhindered’ progress to the next stage.”

She adds: This can’t be considered good practice for meaningful engagement because it does not enable any form of presentation of our concerns to the project team or the committee before their ‘next stage decision-making’.”

The E&L Advertiser asked the council whether it would provide eye-level visuals so people walking and cycling alongside the walls would know what it’s going to look like in reality, rather than just producing bird’s eye views of the defences.

We also asked how the council would address the group’s claims that there was a discrepancy between the council’s overview map and a new video of the works.

The group has produced its own visuals to show to people but because of the discrepancies between the overview map and the new video, they may not be entirely accurate.

The council has not yet replied.

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

Residents distressed over military exercise

And fears over shooting ranges operating without permission

 

Second year of devastation for Newcastleton

Up to 30 homes flooded as river Liddel burst banks

 

Langholm groups reap rewards from the wind

Thousands are paid by the Ewe Hill 6 windfarm to…

 

A big surprise

Congratulations to Rowanburn couple

 

Study identifies top 10 projects for funding

Nearly 1,000 ideas proposed on how to use windfarm grants

 

Operation to change boy’s life costs £25k

Joshua turned down in Scotland but Liverpool hospital steps in

 

Do not feed

Horse nearly dies from treats

 

Sports centre redesign is to be scaled back

Flood plain and funding challenge force rethink on Townfoot

 

Feedback will aid bridge plan

Developer seeks views on active travel

 

Multi-purpose centre will attract thousands

Langholm’s regeneration is on track for an enterprising future

 

GP practices join list of vaccination venues

Over 70s can be vaccinated in the first two weeks…

 

No police here

Crimes go unreported and unrecorded

 

Mass testing deployed after cases spike at 41

Langholm and Eskdale has highest number of cases in district

 

New company will run nature reserve

Estate manager will be recruited to implement moorland plan

 

Course to help women set up their own business comes to Liddesdale

LIDDESDALE has been chosen as one of three rural areas…

 

Eskdale COVID-19 cases second highest

Esk valley comes second only to Gretna in the whole…

 

Rail group argues its case to UK review body

Extension to Carlisle will bring economic and social benefits

 

Over 80s welcome call to receive vaccination

The most elderly in Langholm will be vaccinated from next…

 

A danner for Doddie

DODDIE Weir’s story has touched the rugby world. He played…

 

EWM is sold but not all jobs will be saved

CRITICISM has been levelled at the way Tuesday’s sale of…

 

Kerry’s passion for town lands her the dream job

THE Langholm Alliance has announced the appointment of its project…

 

A Kiwi Christmas

Langholm lass sends positive vibes from a land down under

 

More infectious virus forces new lockdown

Measures close schools and businesses as vaccine is rolled out

 

Better early warning system to be devised

Newcastleton villagers are urged to protect their own houses

 

Ploughing halted after breach of conditions

Forestry watchdog steps in to investigate the loss of deep…

 

From King Herod to the Grinch ....

A Christmas message from Rev Morag Crossan

 

Have yourself a Merry LITTLE Christmas now

It’s a Level Four lockdown from Saturday

 

Reindeer are flying

ALAN Miller’s new tartan reindeer are flying off the shelves…

 

Kevin moves to new post

But he will keep an eye on moor

 

New looms help secure Langholm mill’s future

Drove Weavers expands its capability to meet greater demand

 

Camera plan will combat the lack of police presence

Copshaw’s rural isolation adds to concerns

 

Wetter winters and more hot summers

Met Office says emissions must be cut to avoid extreme…

 

Council refuses to endorse sports centre proposals

Flood plain causes yet more planning problems

 

Amazing ceremony for wildlife watchers

Shortlisted Newcastleton group is celebrated at awards night

 

2020 Magic Lantern Show

ONE of Langholm’s theatre companies is determined to do its…

 

Langholm store marks 20 years of shopping

Co-op staff look forward to 2021 and arrival of a…

 

Vaccination roll-out is imminent: NHS chief

Immunisation of high-priority groups will start next week

 

NHS seeks input on plan

Health and social care and support are at centre of…

 

Happy 400th birthday as town marks charter

Alliance invites groups to host events in run-up to main…

 

200m high turbines for two Eskdale sites

Developer pledges £900,000 a year for nearby communities

 
 
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

This site uses cookies for marketing, personalisation, and analysis purposes. You can opt out of this at any time or view our full privacy policy for more information.