Menu
 
Home | News | Windfarm company take on MoD in court
 
News | 1st May 2020
 

Windfarm company take on MoD in court

 
 
 

Petition on seismic budget allocation will go to judicial review

A DEVELOPER of commercial windfarms, which applied for planning permission for a windfarm within the consultation zone of the Eskdalemuir seismological monitoring station, has succeeded in petitioning a court for a time extension to begin proceedings for judicial review.


The planning application of Energiekontor UK Ltd at the Little Hartfell site was objected to by the Ministry of Defence in accordance with its policy on noise budget.
The petition was heard in the Court of Session by Lord Tyre.
The seismic array comprises seismometers intended to detect vibrations caused by nuclear tests.
Government policy, managed by the MoD, is to protect the array from seismic vibrations from other sources which may interfere with its intended purpose.
The forces acting on wind turbines cause vibrations in their structure which can travel underground for many kilometres.
As a result of a 2005 report, a 10km exclusion zone operates around the array, along with a further 50km consultation zone.
MoD policy is to object to any windfarm development within the exclusion zone and must be notified of any planned developments within the consultation zone.
The report authors recommended a seismic ground vibration threshold for windfarms within the zone, known as the noise budget.

In 2014 another report challenged the 2005 report’s methodology in calculating the noise budget and recommended it be replaced with a physics-based algorithm.
This could allow more windfarms within the exclusion zone. The MoD allocates noise budget on a first-come, first-served basis.
The petitioners applied for planning permission in 2018 for a windfarm with a capacity below 50 megawatts within the consultation zone. The MoD objected because the budget had already been reached.


Before the MOD submitted its formal objection, the petitioner had learned that an objection was likely because all the available noise budget had been allocated to a scopingapplication submitted for an application for a windfarm at Faw Side, Ewes, with a capacity exceeding 50MW.
The petitioner submitted that the MoD’s policy was unreasonable because it treated applications differently, depending on the development’s capacity.
In relation to a proposed development, whose capacity did not exceed 50MW, noise budget was allocated to a development when the MoD was notified by a council’s planning authority of the application.


In relation to a proposed development, whose capacity exceeded 50MW, a budget was allocated when the MoD was notified by the Scottish ministers of a scoping request by the developer for an environmental impact assessment report.
This allowed larger developments to be allocated noise budget at an earlier stage of the planning process than smaller ones. There were, therefore, public policy reasons for allowing the petition to continue.
The MoD opposed the application for a time extension. It had been inappropriate and unreasonable, having regard to the principle of good administration, to wait until the end of 2019 before raising proceedings. Lord Tyre concluded it was equitable to extend the time period. He said: “A consequence of the current MoD policy is that a single, large project, which has not reached the stage of submission of an application, can more than exhaust the available noise budget and operate as a block on windfarm development in a very large area and for an indefinite period.
“I have no view on the petition’s substantive merits, beyond stating I’m satisfied the statutory threshold of real prospect of success is met. “It seems the argument ought to receive judicial consideration and I see no advantage in refusing to allow the petition to proceed.
“The mere fact of permission being granted will not, so far as I am aware, have any immediate practical consequences.

“The current situation is that, because of its proposed capacity, the Faw Side proposal not only exhausts but greatly exceeds the currently available noise budget so there does not appear to be any question of interference with progress with a development which would otherwise be under construction.
“Nor would the remedies sought affect any windfarm development which has already received the relevant planning approval.”
He concluded: “I do not consider that any prejudice to the MoD has been identified. “The petitioner does not dispute that the MoD is entitled to devise and enforce a policy to protect the array from interference with its detection capabilities.”
“The challenge is concerned rather with allocation of priority as between proposed developments, which should be a matter of indifference to the MoD so long as there is noise budget available for allocation.”

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

Scottish Woodlands hear Warblaw concerns

Organisations and residents voice issues at recent Environmental Impact Meeting…

 

And so, it all begins once again!

The Benty Rideout ushers in another Langholm Common Riding fortnight…

 

New one-way system for Elizabeth and Caroline Streets

Proposals put forward further to a request from residents and…

 

Engaging with Ewan

Spur Do 2025 Cornet Patterson being presented with his spurs…

 

Unwanted changes coming to Langholm Town bus service

Lifeline local transport is in danger of having itsoperation reduced…

 

Miraculous sunshine for Ewan’s Street Party

Henry Street and Moodlaw Point residents turned out in force…

 

Further hurdles for Canonbie PO takeover

Canonbie Community Enterprise’sdisappointment with owner’s u-turn Canonbie Community Enterprise (CCE)…

 

Huge message sent to Scotland’s decision-makers

Campaigners are pressing for goats to receive fully-protected status Campaigners…

 

Alan does Doddie proud with 37 Potholm loops

Extreme weather ends marathon effort after a total of 188.5…

 

Academy welcomes inspiring visitor

Challenging disability stereotypes is how Hari overcame adversity Last week…

 

Paul Young to ‘lay his hat’ at The Buccleuch

Paul Young will go back on the road with a…

 

No pot of gold at the end of this ‘rainbow’

SNP to form a minority administration after Conservative split in…

 

Langholm's Front Three have a great Day out at Hawick Common Riding

Read much more in this week’s E&L available at your…

 

Huge attendance at crucial Town Meeting

Strength of feeling of townsfolk made plain to panel…but will…

 

Engaging with Ewan

First visit to the Hut for Langholm’s new Front Three…

 

Let’s get the Muckle Toon back to its former glory

Community Council to chair event where you can have your…

 

Poppy perfection wins Helen’s team a gold at Chelsea

The Meconopsis Group impresses the judges with their display at…

 

Glowing report for Langholm Nursery

Staff delighted after “Very Good” Care Inspectorate visit Staff and…

 

James Ewart Racing ends 21 years of training

Mairi Telford Jammeh speaks to Langholm trainer after surprise racing…

 

After 102 years, LAODS has a new name

Fresh Talent sought for the new season on stage Langholm…

 

D&G Chief pays visit to Langholm organisations

Dumfries and Galloway Council’s Chief Executive Dawn Roberts paid a…

 

Ewan Patterson elected as Langholm’s 2025 Cornet

Over 50% of the town turn out to vote as…

 

Thoughtful VE Day ceremony held at Langholm's War Memorial

RAF Police Sergeant David Patterson led a poignant service at Langholm’s…

 

Well-wishers attend opening of Langholm’s new Post Office

After months of work and training, Elizabeth and staff finally…

 

A quality quartet

Another healthy contingent of fine young men put theirnames forward…

 

Eighty years since Victory in Europe

A poignant reminder of resilience and unity rising from adversity…

 

New Post Office opens on Tuesday

It’s countdown now until the new post office opens on…

 

End of Langholm banking era as BoS closes its doors

Scotland’s oldest bank bows out of High Street The Bank…

 

High-powered visitors

Va-va-vroom! Langholm’s Kilngreen had some very special visitors last weekend…

 

Goat group presses Council

Campaigners want protected status David Braithwaite, Chairman of The Wild…

 

20 might be plenty, but is anyone heeding the signs?

Over the years, the Scottish Government has made so many…

 

Highland surprise on the North Coast 500

The North Coast 500 is a 516-mile scenic route around…

 

Preliminary meeting focusses on Townfoot's hole in the ground

Particular issues discussed in advance of June’s public forum In…

 

Victory in Europe (VE) Day commemoration events

Langholm, Ewes and Westerkirk community council is working with Langholm…

 

Return of full Post Office is first-class news for town

Elizabeth and team are all trained up and ready to…

 

Goat petition reaches MPs

4,000 anti-cull signatures handed over Conservative politicians John Lamont MP…

 

A healing moorland…

Sphagnum moss wound dressings during the Second World War By…

 

Heilan’ Coos and Fell Ponies join the Tarras Valley family

The cows and ponies will play their part in restoring…

 

NHS D&G announces massive funding shortfall

Board seeks public support to manage £33.6 million funding gap…

 

4,000 signature petition to be handed to politicians

Oxygen Conservation’s disregard prompted massive response A local petition with…

 
 
Kelso Races
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This website uses cookies
This site uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience. We use necessary cookies to make sure that our website works. We’d also like to set analytics cookies that help us make improvements by measuring how you use the site. By clicking “Allow All”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyse site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts.
These cookies are required for basic functionalities such as accessing secure areas of the website, remembering previous actions and facilitating the proper display of the website. Necessary cookies are often exempt from requiring user consent as they do not collect personal data and are crucial for the website to perform its core functions.
A “preferences” cookie is used to remember user preferences and settings on a website. These cookies enhance the user experience by allowing the website to remember choices such as language preferences, font size, layout customization, and other similar settings. Preference cookies are not strictly necessary for the basic functioning of the website but contribute to a more personalised and convenient browsing experience for users.
A “statistics” cookie typically refers to cookies that are used to collect anonymous data about how visitors interact with a website. These cookies help website owners understand how users navigate their site, which pages are most frequently visited, how long users spend on each page, and similar metrics. The data collected by statistics cookies is aggregated and anonymized, meaning it does not contain personally identifiable information (PII).
Marketing cookies are used to track user behaviour across websites, allowing advertisers to deliver targeted advertisements based on the user’s interests and preferences. These cookies collect data such as browsing history and interactions with ads to create user profiles. While essential for effective online advertising, obtaining user consent is crucial to comply with privacy regulations.