Menu
 
Home | News | Rural poverty missed
 
News | 6th February 2020
 

Rural poverty missed

 
 
 

Deprivation index is biased towards urban not rural locations

EW figures showing levels of deprivation in Scotland should be treated with caution because they mask rural poverty, it is claimed.
The Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) publication is a tool for identifying the places where people experience disadvantage in different aspects of their lives.
SIMD gives a ranking for 6,976 small areas, or data zones, which shows how deprived an area is compared with other areas.
SIMD is based on measuring poverty using geographical areas.
The index states that deprived does not only mean poor or low income. It can also mean people have fewer resources and opportunities, like health and education.
In rural areas people living in poverty can often be living next to those on high incomes within the geographical area SMID uses.
By measuring the average wealth in an area, SMID doesn’t pick up pockets of poverty in small, rural communities.
Dumfries and Galloway has sparsely-populated and remote rural areas as well as towns and urban neighbourhoods.
Researchers at the University of Glasgow’s Dumfries Campus reviewed local evidence to
inform Dumfries and
Galloway’s poverty strategy.
They used the results of SIMD, along with background data and other information, to look at where people experiencing deprivation live and what issues they face.
SIMD is helpful for decision-makers about how to target
resources but it needs to be used carefully in rural areas.
This is because data zones in rural parts are bigger than those in urban ones and pockets of deprivation are smaller in rural areas.
These are more likely to
include a mix of households experiencing different levels of deprivation.
Influence
Problems with transport and distance to employment and services are very important features of rural deprivation.
They are part of SIMD but have less influence on the overall SIMD rank compared with employment and income.
Jason Railton, Langholm
Initiative’s anti-poverty project manager, said: “New SIMD figures are demonstrating changing levels of deprivation around the country.
“However, it’s recognised that these figures are not necessarily applicable to rural areas like ours because our population is much more sparsely distributed.
“As a result, SIMD does not effectively measure levels of need in our kind of community and they can then be dismissed by policy makers when allocating resources.
“More than half of people on low incomes do not live in the 20 per cent most deprived areas.
“We have to be careful in the language we use around this. It doesn’t help people who live in deprived areas to hear the narrative that their places are ‘bad’ or ‘poor’.
Partners
“We also have to recognise that this system can do a dis
service to people who need support such as in our community.
“As such, we continue to work with our fantastic partners in the charitable and government sectors to ensure support is provided wherever it is needed.”
Colin Smyth, South of Scotland Labour MSP, said the high levels of poverty in communities in Dumfries and Galloway were “unacceptable”.
Parts of Dumfries Central, Summerville, Lochside and
Lincluden, Stranraer West and Stranraer East are all within the top 10 per cent most-
deprived areas.
Parts of Annan East are in the second-most-deprived category.
However, Mr Smyth believes the report underestimates the scale of poverty because SMID often masked rural poverty.
He said: “After the constant Scottish government budget cuts suffered by councils and the welfare cuts from the UK government, I’m not surprised areas of Stranraer, Dumfries and Annan have featured in this report.
Poverty
“The index shows where there are highly-populated areas with a concentration of people on low incomes.
“However, it fails to recognise that the population in rural areas is more spread out, with smaller pockets of real poverty not only in one area. I believe we would benefit from a different measure of rural poverty.
“It beggars belief that in 2020 your postcode can still be the determining factor in your quality of life.
“This is a result of years of complacency from SNP ministers and lack of investment in our communities.
“It must be a wake-up call to ramp up efforts by government to end these shameful inequalities.”

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

‘Blame the Duke’, Loki tells Langholm

By Penny Johnstone Rapper wades into buyout debate in latest…

 

Tub Turnbull’s ‘Ride Oot Bye’

By Gilly Fraser For the first time in three years,…

 

‘My boy is broken-hearted’

Lennon, 12, left devastated after ‘despicable’ thieves target his beloved…

 

Institute raises a cuppa to 100 wonderful years

Retiring president Nancy McLure welcomed members and guests to the…

 

Showing Charolais

By Gilly Fraser “The Royal Highland Show is special for…

 

Drummer Kyle kills it with Brandon & Co

Sheer delight is etched on Kyle Grieve’s face as he…

 

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!

After torrent floods derelict church, residents unite in campaign to…

 

Leila's a vintage virtuoso!

If vintage clothes make you think of mothballs and third-hand…

 

New owners for town's 20-year Erskine eyesore

But clamour grows to tear down derelict, ‘dangerous’ High Street…

 

The blissful sound of silence

Residents celebrate after church bells are finally silenced

 

Let’s do it for Dylan!

As his mum appeals for a life-changing loo in Langholm,…

 

Pyrotechnics and parties for our marvellous monarch

Locals plan to hold a weekend of right royal celebrations

 

'I'm so glad my dad isn't here to see this'

Local opponents hit back at Tarras Valley plans

 

Ruairi to lead the way as Big Day returns at last

Langholm elects its new Cornet with 1,100 votes cast

 

Male is back as just 19 votes decide council seat

Ron Tait ousted in Ward 12 by returning independent candidate

 

Obituary to well loved lady

Tributes paid to much love

 

Last gasp lifeline for Tarras Valley project

Two month extension agreed for £450,000 needed to secure buyout

 

Butchers facing chop

Refurbishment row leads to couple’s decision to quit

 

Care village moves a step closer

£1.4m footbridge will connect new scheme to town

 

Rail group sends signal to Holyrood

New Waverley route must include Langholm say campaigners

 

Election briefing

Use your vote wisely

 

For whom does the bell actually toll?

Parishioners and minister clash over ‘intrusive’ ringing

 

Buccleuch to put 30 homes on the market

Tenants of Buccleuch Estates say they are shocked and distressed…

 

Bus driver crisis is getting serious

Transport company Borders Buses has introduced an emergency timetable after…

 

Ukrainian Hosts meet wall of silence

Generous residents frustrated with housing delays

 

Janet's in the frame for gallery as Phil steps down

By Nick Brownlee It’s the end of an era at…

 

High Noon for Eskdalemuir Marksmen

Opponents claim elite rifle range could put lives at risk

 

End of an era as Common Riding trio announce retirement

By Nick Brownlee Three stalwarts of Langholm Common Riding say…

 

Butcher's face the cruellest of cuts

Heartbreak for couple faced with closure of their High Street…

 

New lease of life for leisure centre plans

Facility would provide “huge health and wellbeing benefits for area”

 

Local plans drawn up to host Ukrainians

Polish charity will match families with hosts in Eskdale

 

"Pristine" items wanted and calls for cash donations

When the call went out last week for donations of…

 

Proud memories of Langholm's Moon Man

On the 50th Anniversary of Neil Armstrong’s Visit

 

Unmanaged vegetation is potential tinderbox

Heather Trust member expresses his concern over wildfires

 

Favourite local walk is changed forever

Gaskell’s footbridge removed over increasing safety concerns

 

Ill-considered approach

Analogue phone switch-off will leave remote communities vulnerable

 

Objections to four hour online consultation

Residents call for more time to examine rifle range scheme

 

Local Authority plans Council Tax hike of 3%

Very difficult decisions will have to be made

 

Digital donations

Young and old receive new computer equipment

 

Residents worried sick over rising prices

Politicians warn of impending cost of living crisis

 
 
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

This site uses cookies for marketing, personalisation, and analysis purposes. You can opt out of this at any time or view our full privacy policy for more information.