Menu
 
Home | News | Flood protection order delayed by fresh study
 
News | 1st October 2020
 

Flood protection order delayed by fresh study

Environmental impact assessment will take six months to do

 
 
The River Esk meets the Wauchope below Langholm parish church and the water level rises dramatically after Monday's heavy rain Dec 30 13 R Norris
 

SCOTLAND’S environmental watchdog has delayed progress of Langholm’s flood protection scheme by insisting on an environmental impact assessment (EIA).

Today Dumfries and Galloway Council’s communities committee was being recommended to give the go-ahead to the flood order being published.

But there will now be a six-month delay with extra costs of up to £70,000 to pay for the EIA.

The council’s flood risk management team consulted the community on its preferred option of direct defences, comprising walls and embankments, with an overflow channel through Buccleuch Park to relieve flow on the Wauchope during high flow events.

The current estimated cost is £9.9m.

While preparing documents for publication later this month, the council was advised by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) that the scheme must have an EIA completed and this will take about six months.

The Water Framework Directive assessment identified that the scheme had the potential to cause a deterioration of the morphological (the shape / form of the river channel and how that can change over time) status of the Esk and Wauchope.

SEPA’s view is that that the works may lead to deterioration of the water environment beyond the location of the defences.

The cost is estimated at £50,000 to £70,000.

The report to today’s meeting said: “Legislation does not require any additional engagement before proceeding to the scheme’s publication but the project team considers it’s important to re-engage with people and see whether any issue can be addressed before the publication process rather than after.

“The team is aware of opposition, particularly to the height and scale of some of the defences and the adverse effect it may have on the town.

“Before committing more spend, particularly the EIA, it is recommended another engagement event is held.

“Enhancements to the computer-generated 3D model are being developed to show more walk-through visuals of the defences.

“There is an option to install full-scale mock-ups of sections of the defences on site to give people as accurate representation as possible.”

Such an event would be affected by COVID-19 restrictions but the construction and installation of mock-ups could be done later in the year.

The report added: “Public feedback on the scale of defences necessary to achieve the design level of protection would help to determine the likelihood of formal objections and inform members in making decisions on progressing the scheme.

“Depending on how quickly the mock-ups could be installed, this approach would put back the timetable by three to six months.

“If, after the engagement, members decided to proceed, we would do the EIA and the scheme would proceed as planned.”

It is anticipated that the public engagement would run from November to April and a report go to committee in May.

The detailed design would be completed in 2025/6 followed by the construction.

The flood defences review group, which is calling for a design review, has welcomed the temporary reprieve but is disappointed there is no mention of a review to deal with the issues they raised.

It welcomes the proposal for the on-site mock-ups but says it’s only an enhanced sales-pitch for the same scheme currently on the table.

The group wrote to councillor Andy Ferguson, committee chairman, asking for a review.

In his response Mr Ferguson said: “I know Langholm well and I’m only too aware of the devastation flooding causes when the Esk and Ewes are in full spate.

“I’m considering the points you raise and I’ll discuss them with the flood risk management team.

“Whichever option is preferred, there will be further engagement with the community on it before it is formally published.”

In a statement, the group said: “Public engagement and offering opportunities to influence the design are two entirely different things.”

In its correspondence with the group, the council’s team wrote: “We’re preparing another ‘virtual tour’ to enable people to go online and view the defences from an eye-level perspective at about a dozen locations along the river and then rotate the view to look back and forth along the defences.

“This will be accompanied by still images which include the appropriate defence heights.

“This virtual tour has been created from scratch because the 3D model did not provide the quality needed for such enhanced visuals because the work is detailed and time-consuming.”

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

High heid yins head for Thomas Hope meeting

Meeting with Health and Social Care to thrash out Langholm’s…

 

Having a final say on the future of Holm Hill

Newcastleton and District Community Trust is just about to carry…

 

Love, a dance and a right good belly laugh!

With a large cast and great audiences, LAODS’ Last Tango…

 

Share in windfarm leadsto green awards nomination

Nick Jennings’ foresight puts Eskdalemuir in the running The Upper…

 

Langholm Alliance: Update on Community Plan

Donna Hislop, Community Enterprise Manager, brings us up to speed…

 

Musical excellence delights Canonbie audience

Splendid concert brings church’s 200 year celebrations to a close…

 

Langholm Moor Lynx fears are calmed... for the moment

Fears that the new owners of former farmland on Langholm…

 

Oxygen Man links lynx to Langholm Moor

Blackburn & Hartsgarth owner says it’s a possibility Could former…

 

Post Office's future discussed at meeting

Canonbie residents gather to hear the options for valuable village…

 

Scottish call-up forathlete sisters

Langholm siblings make the Scottish Pentathlon team SCOTTISH CALL UP…

 

Langholm familiarisation visit for Council leader

Gail Macgregor, leader of Dumfries and Galloway Council was invited…

 

Further afforestation fury

Tree planting nightmare for a further three farms surrounding Claygate…

 

Moderator inspires worshipers at Canonbie

Church is packed to hear uplifting service from church leader…

 

Urgent action required in face of diminished services

1,000+ signature petition endorses demands Langholm’s ailing health services are…

 

Public meeting on future of Canonbie Post Office

Following the news that Canonbie Post Office and shop were…

 

Appeal for help with gardens

Margaret Pool writes; A number of folk will recall that…

 

Rothbury 'Looks North' to Langholm for guidance

The team at BBC look North got in touch with…

 

High profile minister to visit Canonbie

Anthony Lane tells of perfect ending to Church’s bi-centenary events…

 

Langholm Flood Scheme dead in the water

Plug pulled on original £10 million defences In last week’s…

 

A celebration of some amazing achievements

Langholm Academy pupils shine with some spectacular exam results and…

 

Old Copshaw hostlery closes its doors

One of Newcastleton’s longest-established businesses has closed down. The Liddesdale…

 

Xcel is eighteen!

This week marks 18 years of the Xcel Project! The…

 

Doing the Wright thing for Sycamore Gap

Amazing offer by Canonbie Sawmill owners Canonbie sawmill owners Steve…

 

Ultra-cool Ullswater adventures

Langholm S6 pupils enjoy a week of outdoor antics and…

 

Umbrella walkers raise over £30k

Rotary and Trusts-backed fundraiser breaks another record The Langholm Rotary…

 

Conan has Carolina on his mind

Langholm athlete settled on Charleston SouthernUniversity having had seventy offers…

 

Loreburn remains 'wholly committed' to Murtholm

E&L interviews housing association chief executive Kirsteen McGinn The E&L…

 

Had by Haddington

Slow start for Langholm gives home side the advantage but…

 

The 171st Langholm Show

The day of the 171st Langholm Show dawned and Langholm…

 

Sensational new sensory room for Langholm Youth project

Xcel has provided one of the best publicly accessible sensory…

 

All our rugby yesteryears

A great afternoon at Hawick and Wilton Cricket Club on…

 

Cammy Barnes LOVES Langholm x

Last Friday, The Buccleuch Centre opened it’s doors to welcome…

 

Langholm Forum contacts Holyrood

Warbla petition prompts invitation to Gougeon Following an excellent response…

 

It’s been all go on Langholm Showfield this week.

A veritable army of willing volunteers and committee members has…

 

Indefinite delay for Murtholm development

Loreburn announce moratorium on new-builds But promise Langholm project is…

 

Flat roof problems for Langholm's Primary school

Wet rot and

From no RAAC one week to wet rot and water…

 

Erskine Church saga reaches the airwaves

Denise Irving-Lang to be interviewed by Radio Scotland It’s encouraging…

 

Eskdale & Liddesdale schools declared safe

Wet rot and

No RAAC detected in preliminary inspections Councillor Denis Male contacted…

 

Langholm Day Centre grow their own

There’s nothing quite like the taste of home-grown tomatoes and…

 

Cheers! Langholm's Beer Festival hailed a huge success

Joint venture by Buccleuch Centre and Borderlands Brewery goes down…

 
 
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

This site uses cookies for marketing, personalisation, and analysis purposes. You can opt out of this at any time or view our full privacy policy for more information.