Menu
 
Home | News | Day’s tree appeal dismissed
 
News | 3rd April 2020
 

Day’s tree appeal dismissed

 
 
Edinburgh Woollen Mill chief executive Philip Day, who lives at Hayton, near Carlisle. S210135.jpg
 

PHILLIP Day, owner of The Edinburgh Woollen Mill, has lost his appeal against his international firm of solicitors, Womble Bond Dickinson, after he was prosecuted for felling 43 trees on a site of special scientific interest in 2010 and constructing a vehicle track.
According to The Law Society Gazette, the Court of Appeal sided with the solicitors in negligence proceedings brought by a convicted former client, stating the litigation was ‘inappropriate, wasteful of resources, and likely to bring the law into disrepute’.
Day was fined £450,000 and ordered to pay £457,317 in costs by the Crown court after felling the trees on his estate in Cumbria. At the time it was also alleged that he had made ‘vigorous efforts’ to obstruct local residents reporting his actions to Natural England by threatening and bullying them.
He appealed against the Court decision on the grounds that Womble Bond Dickinson were guilty of professional negligence, arguing that there was an abuse of process argument which should have been run on his behalf in the criminal proceedings and that the firm failed to advise him to plead his case in the magistrates’ court rather than the Crown court.
The Court of Appeal dismissed most of Day’s appeal and Lord Justice McCombe, Lord Justice Floyd and Lord Justice Coulson found that the abuse of process argument contravened the doctrine of illegality and was an abusive collateral attack on Day’s criminal conviction and sentence.
‘The abuse argument is being pursued because it is an essential part of the appellant’s continuing refusal to accept his conviction and sentence. In such circumstances, it is hard to imagine a clearer collateral attack on the conclusions of the Crown Court’ they concluded.
They added that Day had ‘left no stone unturned in seeking to avoid his liability for the destruction in Gelt Woods’.
The Court of Appeal said that attempts to reduce Day’s fine and Natural England’s costs were rightly struck out. It concluded, however with ‘reluctance’ that ‘it is open to the appellant to argue that his costs were higher than they should have been because of the alleged negligence on the part of Womble Bond Dickinson in respect of the
appropriate venue. To that limited extent, I would allow the appeal’.
Lord Justice McCombe concluded that it was ‘sensible and necessary for the final decisions in criminal courts to be just that – final – and that subsequent satellite litigation, re-arguing points that could and should have been raised before, and which went directly or indirectly to undermine the conviction and its consequences, was inappropriate wasteful of resources, and likely to bring the law into disrepute”

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

Ruairi to lead the way as Big Day returns at last

Langholm elects its new Cornet with 1,100 votes cast

 

Male is back as just 19 votes decide council seat

Ron Tait ousted in Ward 12 by returning independent candidate

 

Obituary to well loved lady

Tributes paid to much love

 

Last gasp lifeline for Tarras Valley project

Two month extension agreed for £450,000 needed to secure buyout

 

Butchers facing chop

Refurbishment row leads to couple’s decision to quit

 

Care village moves a step closer

£1.4m footbridge will connect new scheme to town

 

Rail group sends signal to Holyrood

New Waverley route must include Langholm say campaigners

 

Election briefing

Use your vote wisely

 

For whom does the bell actually toll?

Parishioners and minister clash over ‘intrusive’ ringing

 

Buccleuch to put 30 homes on the market

Tenants of Buccleuch Estates say they are shocked and distressed…

 

Bus driver crisis is getting serious

Transport company Borders Buses has introduced an emergency timetable after…

 

Ukrainian Hosts meet wall of silence

Generous residents frustrated with housing delays

 

Janet's in the frame for gallery as Phil steps down

By Nick Brownlee It’s the end of an era at…

 

High Noon for Eskdalemuir Marksmen

Opponents claim elite rifle range could put lives at risk

 

End of an era as Common Riding trio announce retirement

By Nick Brownlee Three stalwarts of Langholm Common Riding say…

 

Butcher's face the cruellest of cuts

Heartbreak for couple faced with closure of their High Street…

 

New lease of life for leisure centre plans

Facility would provide “huge health and wellbeing benefits for area”

 

Local plans drawn up to host Ukrainians

Polish charity will match families with hosts in Eskdale

 

"Pristine" items wanted and calls for cash donations

When the call went out last week for donations of…

 

Proud memories of Langholm's Moon Man

On the 50th Anniversary of Neil Armstrong’s Visit

 

Unmanaged vegetation is potential tinderbox

Heather Trust member expresses his concern over wildfires

 

Favourite local walk is changed forever

Gaskell’s footbridge removed over increasing safety concerns

 

Ill-considered approach

Analogue phone switch-off will leave remote communities vulnerable

 

Objections to four hour online consultation

Residents call for more time to examine rifle range scheme

 

Local Authority plans Council Tax hike of 3%

Very difficult decisions will have to be made

 

Digital donations

Young and old receive new computer equipment

 

Residents worried sick over rising prices

Politicians warn of impending cost of living crisis

 

Holey Unacceptable

Stock reply from Council leaves road users frustrated and angry

 

D&G Council objects to Faw Side turbines

Borders QC takes on fight against windfarm

 

Opposition advised over Faw Side Windfarm

Windfarm would be inappropriate and overbearing

 

Common Ridings

Organisations hail return of ancient celebrations

 

Significant uncertainty surrounding flood scheme

Concerned residents say the plans will be unaffordable and undeliverable

 

Knock back for shooting range

Developers will carry on with plan for training facility

 

Park Drain Ditched

Council remove drainage channel from park in flood scheme proposals

 

We welcome Penny as new community editor

Penny Johnstone brings her positivity and experience to the E&L

 

Confidence will return

Talk of change from Pandemic to endemic gives businesses hope

 

Massive donation to Tarras Valley Reserve

Anonymous donor takes funding over the quarter-way mark

 

Communities have pulled together despite the setbacks

Better days are coming, so let’s all look forward to…

 

Scott’s coachman

Langholm sisters investigate their forebears

 

Everyone encouraged to follow new Covid rules

Evidence suggests Omicron cases are set to double every two…

 
 
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

This site uses cookies for marketing, personalisation, and analysis purposes. You can opt out of this at any time or view our full privacy policy for more information.