Menu
 
Home | News | Day’s tree appeal dismissed
 
News | 3rd April 2020
 

Day’s tree appeal dismissed

 
 
Edinburgh Woollen Mill chief executive Philip Day, who lives at Hayton, near Carlisle. S210135.jpg
 

PHILLIP Day, owner of The Edinburgh Woollen Mill, has lost his appeal against his international firm of solicitors, Womble Bond Dickinson, after he was prosecuted for felling 43 trees on a site of special scientific interest in 2010 and constructing a vehicle track.
According to The Law Society Gazette, the Court of Appeal sided with the solicitors in negligence proceedings brought by a convicted former client, stating the litigation was ‘inappropriate, wasteful of resources, and likely to bring the law into disrepute’.
Day was fined £450,000 and ordered to pay £457,317 in costs by the Crown court after felling the trees on his estate in Cumbria. At the time it was also alleged that he had made ‘vigorous efforts’ to obstruct local residents reporting his actions to Natural England by threatening and bullying them.
He appealed against the Court decision on the grounds that Womble Bond Dickinson were guilty of professional negligence, arguing that there was an abuse of process argument which should have been run on his behalf in the criminal proceedings and that the firm failed to advise him to plead his case in the magistrates’ court rather than the Crown court.
The Court of Appeal dismissed most of Day’s appeal and Lord Justice McCombe, Lord Justice Floyd and Lord Justice Coulson found that the abuse of process argument contravened the doctrine of illegality and was an abusive collateral attack on Day’s criminal conviction and sentence.
‘The abuse argument is being pursued because it is an essential part of the appellant’s continuing refusal to accept his conviction and sentence. In such circumstances, it is hard to imagine a clearer collateral attack on the conclusions of the Crown Court’ they concluded.
They added that Day had ‘left no stone unturned in seeking to avoid his liability for the destruction in Gelt Woods’.
The Court of Appeal said that attempts to reduce Day’s fine and Natural England’s costs were rightly struck out. It concluded, however with ‘reluctance’ that ‘it is open to the appellant to argue that his costs were higher than they should have been because of the alleged negligence on the part of Womble Bond Dickinson in respect of the
appropriate venue. To that limited extent, I would allow the appeal’.
Lord Justice McCombe concluded that it was ‘sensible and necessary for the final decisions in criminal courts to be just that – final – and that subsequent satellite litigation, re-arguing points that could and should have been raised before, and which went directly or indirectly to undermine the conviction and its consequences, was inappropriate wasteful of resources, and likely to bring the law into disrepute”

 
 
Would you like to support us?

The Eskdale and Liddesdale Advertiser is our community owned local newspaper and even in today’s troubled times, we aim to bring you local news and articles in an impartial, responsible and factual way.

We hope you have enjoyed reading this free article but we need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and independent and keeps you up to date with what is happening in Eskdale and Liddesdale.

Every reader’s contribution, however big or small, is so valuable to us.
 
 
‘Owned by the Community...Published for the Community’
Do you have a story?

Please get in touch if you have a story or article you would like to see published.

Related Articles

Time is running out to buy town’s moorland

It’s a race to the finish as deadline of October…

 

Day of reckoning

EWM chain’s future is in doubt if group’s owner saves…

 

Flood Scheme Forum

RESIDENTS living in riverside properties in Langholm have voiced their…

 

Langholm Loves Local launched

LANGHOLM is bouncing back with a new initiative to make…

 

New coronavirus rules will not help industry

Hotel owner criticises Scottish government for unclear message

 

Pandemic infects iconic retail brand

More unemployment as Day puts EWM Group in administration

 

Villagers welcome a 20mph limit trial

Newcastleton’s streets will be safer for pedestrians and drivers

 

EWM TO CLOSE 200 STORES IN NEXT FORTNIGHT

24,000 Jobs are at risk

 

Village sewage works due to open next spring

Canonbie and the River Esk will benefit from better treatment

 

Housing developer is ready to move onto site

Plan put in for initial works, including improved A7 junction

 

Rescued mill has new name and big plans

Drove Weavers in Langholm earns praise and admiration from MSP

 

Digital skills project is launched in Langholm

Older people, young people and low-income families targeted

 

Flood protection order delayed by fresh study

Environmental impact assessment will take six months to do

 

Team appointed to regenerate Copshaw

Development officer to lead transformation of Buccleuch House

 

Four more defibrillators go live

FOUR more defibrillators have been installed as part of a…

 

Centre design rethink after public response

And council calls for extra study after identifying flood risk

 

Village completes historic land buy-out

Newcastleton trust buys 750 acres of Holm Hill from Buccleuch

 

Scottish actor appeals for donations to moor

Gregor has good memories of raising his family in Langholm

 

Dyehouse cuts ten jobs as orders dry up

COVID-19 pandemic hits successful company’s customers

 

Plan launched to make south a greater place

Enterprise body to make area centre for opportunity, innovation and…

 

Volunteers needed to drive community car

New Caddy will be used to transport residents to appointments

 

Another million given to moorland buyout

South of Scotland Enterprise give huge boost to venture

 

Centre bids for funding to survive the long term

Langholm’s popular performing arts venue is vital to economy

 

Academy’s head pupils

LANGHOLM and Canonbie Schools Cluster is delighted to announce the…

 

Church reopens for worship

By the Rev Dr. Robert Pickles

 

YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS!

Artists impression of how proposed flood defences may look

 

£500k boost for moor

Family foundation breathes new life into bid for nature reserve

 

Langholm’s last mill has a brighter future

Well-known designer will create jobs and establish new brand

 

Nicol’s enterprising role to regenerate town

Former Langholm man will deliver Langholm’s action plan

 

Dance scholar rewarded

A PERFORMING arts student from Langholm has won a coveted…

 

Centre announces an August reopening

Coffees and lunches are back on the menu – at…

 

Canonbie surgery

A CONFIDENTIAL online consultation service giving patients another way to…

 

Town is a high priority

Langholm does not rank the lowest in an index based…

 

MARVELLOUS!

IT WAS dark when three horsemen were greeted by a…

 

Neighbourly celebrations

MOODLAW Point and Henry Street South neighbours gathered on Jennety’s…

 

Neighbourly celebrations

THE neighbours in Academy Place and Douglas Terrace could not…

 

Partnership secures £2.1m for the south

Scottish government awards funding to 28 innovative projects

 

Jobless warning

JUNE’S unemployment figures are just the ‘tip of the iceberg’…

 

Weaving company’s future in the balance

Management buy-out team seeks to progress talks with owner

 

Defibs are going live

Life-saving equipment will come with full instructions on use

 
Surgery Tour 2020
 
requires mailchimp logins and wired up to a list
Join our mailing list
Keep up to date with all that’s going on at the E&L
This site uses cookies.
Configure
 
Read our privacy policy

This site uses cookies for marketing, personalisation, and analysis purposes. You can opt out of this at any time or view our full privacy policy for more information.